AFP Sues Elon Musk's X

09:45, Johannesburg, Thursday, 03/08/23
French news outlet Agence France-Presse (AFP) has indeed  filed a lawsuit against Elon Musk’s X social media company where AFP accuses X of refusing to engage in discussions about payments for the distribution of news.

The lawsuit catalyzed on the back of a law passed by the European Union in 2019 which obligates online platforms to negotiate remuneration for news with publishers.

Global online news publications have long advocated for social media and internet platforms such as X, Meta and Google share profits generated from the hosting of their content.
Such calls for profit sharing seem to be gaining traction as Canada in July of 2023 enacted a law requiring large internet platforms to compensate news publishers for the content, following the adoption of a similar model by Australia in 2021.

In response to this new legislation by Canda, Facebook and Instagram parent company 'Meta' on Tuesday announced that it had begun the process of ending access to news for users in Canada.

Meanwhile Alphabet, the parent company of Google, signed a deal with French publishers in 2022 to pay for content that appears in search engine results. This came after France’s anti-trust watchdog fined the tech giant 500 million euros or $547m for failing to enter negotiations.

Elon Musk however has dismissed the lawsuit with disdain calling the suit 'bizarre'. Musk was quoted as saying:
"They want us to pay *them* for traffic to their site where they make advertising revenue and we don’t!?”.

X has said that it is still consulting with it's legal team and would respond to the lawsuit in due course.

Written by Thabo Makaota, Senior Researcher and Writer @TheLegalSA

Musk Mulls Suing Zuckerberg

13:45pm, Friday, 07/07/23, Johannesburg

Two of the wealthiest men on the planet Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg are on a potential legal battle collision course over their respective social media platforms.

On Wednesday, Zuckerberg launched his 'Threads' social media platform which parent company META has said has garnered over 30-million users in less that 78-hours.

Threads is a similar social media app to Twitter and this has gotten Musk very very tight as millennials would say.

Musk is considering legal action against Meta, contending that "competition is fine, cheating is not".

Threads is uncannily similar to Twitter but where do you draw the line of how social media apps can do and must look like?

According to an America Securities Exchange Commission  filing from 2013, Twitter four years to build the same number of users that Threads app gained in a single day day (30 million users).

Threads defended the advantage saying that it was able to tap into the pre-existing two billion monthly users parent company Meta says Instagram has.

Elon Musk will face an uphill battle in court as US copyright law does not protect ideas, meaning that for Twitter to be successful in an intellectual property violation against Threads in court it would have to prove that its own intellectual property, such as programming code, was copied.

Furthermore, META currently holds a patent for "communicating a newsfeed" which is the system that displays all the latest posts when you use Facebook, where META contends that it uses it's own technology to run Threads.

Uploaded videos on Threads can be 5-minutes long, well over the 2-minutes provisioned for standard Twitter users.

You can't use hashtags on Threads but you can on Twitter.


There are no 'trending stories' on Threads but there are on Twitter.

These are some of the differences between the two social media companies owned by two of some of the richest men in the world.

Written by Thabo Makaota, senior writer @TheLegalSA